Oldest quran carbon dating

Rated 3.95/5 based on 737 customer reviews

But it’s also entirely possible, even without this consideration, that the parchment fragments could predate their use as material for a written Qurʾān by centuries.Based on the above, it is sad to think that anyone, particularly with an academic background, takes seriously the notion that the contents of the Birmingham manuscript actually predate the Prophet’s lifetime.In other words, even the parts of the Qurʾān that are not held to be prophetic in a predictive sense suddenly have their value upgraded to just that.3.There is no contextual historical evidence to suggest that any of the Qurʾān predates the accepted time frame of revelation.4.

oldest quran carbon dating-9

Such discrepancies can usually be attributed to the fact that carbon-dating provides a reasonably accurate assessment of the date of the medium of writing—for example, the death date of an animal whose skin is used for writing on—rather than the date when of the writing itself. Two Quran fragments unknowingly held since 1936 in the University of Birmingham’s manuscript collection have been definitively dated to the era of Muhammad’s life or a little later.The writing of the two folios (with text corresponding to chapters 18-20 in the modern Quran) has been placed somewhere between 568 and 645 CE, which is very close to the conventional dating offered for the Prophet’s ministry, 610-632 CE.No manuscripts or studies or science suggest that the Qurʾān predates the Prophet Muḥammad.At best, every headline should have been a variation of “Birmingham manuscript suggests that an animal lived before the lifetime of Muḥammad.” But then, I suppose that’s not very interesting news.2.

Leave a Reply