But now, some fans of the show are questioning everything after seeing Alexis and fellow finalist Milo Manheim in several Instagrams together.
It all started when Alexis posted a photo of herself lying in Milo's lap with the caption, "is this seat taken? Another exclaimed that she was "so confused."Meanwhile, on Milo's Instagram account, he posted two photos from the same day with the caption, "the other snack that smiles back." On Milo's pictures, people also freaked out over the photo shoot.
He has made guest appearance in many popular TV series like the Teenage Witch, Law and Order: Special Victims Unit, CSI: Crime Scene Investigation and Sabrina.
In 2009 he was awarded with Teen Choice Awards for his outstanding acting.
He was rumored to be dating beautiful actress Emmy Rossum but the rumor never got officially confirmed.
And good news for his fan girls is that he is currently single.
Two days ago, the pro dancer shared a thoughtful happy birthday message and said he "couldn't wait to celebrate" with Alexis.
On top of that, the 24-year-old dancer posted a ridiculously cute picture of the two smiling together.
His parents are Carol Ventimiglia and Peter Ventimiglia.
Moreover, he also has two older sisters named Leslie and Laurel.